I taught Quentin Neujar (of the Jaxonville Jaguars) swing dance lessons when we were at KState.

Dan Smith (former baseball player) is a friend of ours.  He only played professional for 8 years, and moved around quite a bit.  He also dated our niece when they were in HS.  Aaron McConnell is also from Girard.  He just signed a Arena League contract with the Alabama Vipers.  He had been with the Tenessee Titans at one time.

Don't know if these lesser-known former athletes count or not, but that is as close as I get!