KSBoy has all of his favorite recipes in a Word document that is easy to search.  It is a real treasury, and I like the "online" aspect of it.  I've still printed it out; one day I will get organized and incorporate it into my series of binders with my other recipes. 

I think this is a great idea no matter what form it takes.  Having a section where you could make a review is great too, but maybe it'd be too much maintenance for this site?  I know we are all busy.