We have used both and switched back and forth over the years. For us it is easy to set a pallet of it on the tender wagon and last a long time. Seems like we did not have enough storage on the trailer to where we were always having to run to the coop or another dealer to get the shuttle filled where we were buying it in bulk from them. With the dry we have enough pallets at home for the season and just set one on the tender trailer as needed. Proximity to where we load the bulk liquid was not always convenient. If we were buying in shuttles and had enough shuttles for the season in the shed ahead of time the liquid would probably work as good or better than the dry. Its going to get the shuttles filled is why we switched over. Don't use screens in your tips if you use dry and we never have any problem with it.

John