AgTalk Home
AgTalk Home
Search Forums | Classifieds | Skins | Language
You are logged in as a guest. ( logon | register )

Mother's Day trip in the EV
View previous thread :: View next thread
   Forums List -> AgTalk CafeMessage format
 
1972RedNeck
Posted 5/13/2024 23:20 (#10739167 - in reply to #10739079)
Subject: RE: GM, Bolt EUV and Tesla EVs


Townsend, Montana
Jim - 5/13/2024 21:41
Your logic on "hybrid" diesel-electric railroad locomotives is a bit off target. It had nothing to do with the availability of "cheap" western electric power but with the physics of starting a long train or going up a mountain. The electric motors used on locomotives have tremendous zero speed startupĀ  torque, as required to get a train moving or to climb a hill. But to do so requires incredible amount of electrical current. And as trains got larger the batteries and/or wires etc required to store or transmit that power got larger and larger. It made a lot of sense to put a large, diesel powered generator in each locomotive to generate the needed electricity rather than string more wires or 3rd rails or charging stations through the countryside. Then you could also add a second or third locomotive to a train without overloading the electrical transmission system or killing the batteries of the time. The weight of the large diesel engine and generator also added weight and traction to locomotives which was useful as train got longer and heavier especially in the mountains.

Hybrid diesel-electric railroad locomotives have almost nothing to do with present day automotive gas-electric hybrid automobiles although the same diesel-electric hybrid concept may be useful in large over the road trucks in the future.



When you put even a car on the likes of Teton pass, the physics you reference apply directly to highway vehicles as well. Hence why I referenced the "mountainous" part of the US.

It seems to make a lot of sense to put an internal combustion engine in a car to help drive the electric motors as well instead of stringing charging stations through the countryside. If it wasn't for government money, there never would have been an electric rail line in Montana.

I am all for EVs that can stand on their own merits. I hope to own one in the near future. But living in a little valley that has a respectable mountain pass on all 7 roads that lead out of the valley, as well as most of them leading to the middle of nowhere, it is easy for me to see the problems with EVs.
Top of the page Bottom of the page


Jump to forum :
Search this forum
Printer friendly version
E-mail a link to this thread

(Delete cookies)